Tuesday, 19 November 2013

Can Russia become a superpower again?

CAN RUSSIA BECOME A WORLD POWER AGAIN
August 2013                                       



1.         Soviet Union came into being in 1922 through a treaty where in Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and the Caucausus states merged together through a treaty to form the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.  Joseph Stalin came to power in 1924 following Lenin’s death and he immediately set the country on a different course. He introduced an economic plan dictated from the top. Agricultural lands were collectivized, creating large, state-run farms. Industrial development was pushed along at breakneck speed, and production was almost entirely diverted from consumer products to capital equipment. Art and literature were placed under much tighter control, and the radical energy of the Russian Avant-Garde was replaced by the solemn grandeur of Soviet realism. Religion was violently repressed, as churches were closed, destroyed, or converted to other uses. Stalin purged all opposition to himself within the party as well as all opposition to party policy in the country. By the end of the 1930s, the Soviet Union had become a country in which life was more strictly regulated than ever before.

2.         By the beginning of Second World War, Soviet Union had emerged as a power to reckon with. The country played a crucial role in stopping the German advance and inflicted a decisive defeat on the Germans, which eventually led to the German defeat in the world war. Although the country suffered enormous devastation and lost more than twenty million lives, it had gained considerable territory and now ranked as one of the two great world powers along with the United States. Nonetheless, life in the country continued to suffer. Industrial production was once again concentrated on heavy industry, agricultural failures produced widespread famine, political freedoms were restricted even further, and another huge wave of purges was carried out. As the Cold War got underway, an increasing proportion of the Soviet Union's resources were funneled into military projects, further exacerbating the quality of life. The cold war intensified over the next decades and finally ended with the collapse of USSR in 1991.

3.         Though Soviet Union was a great military power and had great influence across the Globe on many issues, the internal situation inside the country was something different. Even at the peak of Cold war, Soviet economy was just about a quarter of the US economy. This effectively resulted in almost 25-30 % of the GDP being spent on military expenses. Consequently agriculture, industry and welfare activities stagnated leading to widespread discontent among the population. When Mikhail Gorbachev came into power in 1985, the Russian structure was beyond efficient administration over a long term and he introduced measures to create a new Soviet Union. Gorbachev's platform for a new Soviet Union was founded on two now-famous terms - glasnost (openness) and perestroika (restructuring). Restructuring began in earnest, with a vigorous housecleaning of the bureaucracy and a significant investigation into corruption. Glasnost, however, lost some credibility right at the outset when it was discovered in April 1986 that the government had waited several days before admitting to the infamous nuclear disaster at Chernobyl--a reactor explosion that had thrown radioactive material over a wide area of the country. Backed into a corner on Chernobyl, Gorbachev countered with the dramatic removal of all controls on reporting and at that point the fresh air really began to howl. For the first time in decades, the problems of the country became subjects for open public discussion. Poverty, corruption, the enormous mismanagement of the country's resources, the unpopularity of the Afghan war, and a host of other problems and grievances were raised against the Government.

4.         In the spring of 1989, the first open elections since 1917 were held, allowing voters a novel choice of more than one candidate for seats in the Congress of People's Deputies. The governments of the Soviet satellite states in Eastern Europe, subjected to the same rising tide of public criticism, fell one after the other in a rapid series of revolutions culminating in the fall of the Berlin wall. In 1990, the Soviet Union itself began to unravel. Its own constituent republics began to issue declarations of independence starting with the  Baltic states, Caucasus and finally Central Asia.  By the end of the 1991, the Soviet Union had been voted out of existence, to be replaced by a Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS). On December 25, Gorbachev resigned, and on midnight of December 31, the Soviet flag atop the Kremlin was replaced by the Russian tricolour.


CIS Post Collapse

5.         Since the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Russia tried to develop a market economy and achieve consistent economic growth. In October 1991, Yeltsin announced that Russia would proceed with radical, market-oriented reform as recommended by the IMF. However, this policy resulted in economic collapse, with millions being plunged into poverty and corruption and crime spreading rapidly. Removal of price control resulted in hyper inflation, reaching 1500 % by mid 90s. The result was a rapid decline in the value of the ruble, flight of foreign investment, delayed payments on sovereign and private debts, a breakdown of commercial transactions through the banking system, and the threat of continued runaway inflation.  To make matters worse, assuming the role as the sequel to the legal personality of the Soviet Union, Russia took up the responsibility for settling the USSR's external debts, even though its population made up just half of the population of the USSR at the time of its dissolution.

6.         Decline of Military.   The hard core of Soviet power was, of course, a formidable military widely regarded for much of the Cold War as superior to the combined defense exertions of a global coalition of industrial democracies. In the Soviet era, the Western security debate was haunted by images of a Soviet military juggernaut. Soviet military power was thought by many to be capable of conquering Europe, dominating Eurasia, and besting the United States in the global competition between East and West. The demise of the Soviet Union left behind this vast military machine, now broken into pieces and serving various newly independent masters.  Over the course of the 1990s, the capitol that once commanded an apparent military juggernaut witnessed the substantial melting away of much of its military power. The distribution of military assets was based on a treaty between the new republics, ironically under the guidance of NATO. One good thing that happened in spite of the distribution of the military assets was the consolidation of nuclear arsenal which were located at different locations in the hands of Russia. This of course buttressed Soviet conventional capabilities by providing the country with  many thousands of warheads and several thousand delivery systems.

7.         The decline of the economy had its effect on the military too. Sudden decline in military budget caused improper or no maintenance on equipment. Many of the equipment became obsolete by the end of nineties. Most of the remaining were rendered non operational. The defence industry collapsed. New inductions were no more in the pipeline. The military budget shrank to a low of 30 billion dollars by 1998 resulting in loss of morale amongst men and unserviceability of equipment.

Year
Expenditure in bn dollars
1988
443
1989
406
1990
376
1991
324
1992
87
1993
74
1994
71
1995
46
1996
42
1997
45
1998
30


Russian Reemergence

8.         It was against the backdrop of uncertain and bleak future that Vladimir Putin took over Russian presidency in 2000. An ardant fan of soviet union and a former KGB man, he was quick to consolidate power and bring all govt and military machinery under his personal control. He made dedicated efforts to regularize the privatization of Russian Industries. The markets were regularized, strict control established over the economy and private industrialization was streamlined. Firm plans were made and executed to rejuvenate the economy and to put Russia on the path to recovery.

9.         During Putin's first eight years in office, the industry grew by 75%, investments increased by 125%, and agricultural production and construction increased as well. Real incomes more than doubled and the average salary increased eightfold from $80 to $640. The GDP doubled, climbing from 22nd place to 11th place in the world during this period. By 2007, Russian GDP was more than what it was in 1990, prior to the disintegration of USSR.
Putin was the messiah for many Russians, who started witnessing better standards of living.

10.       Most important aspect of Russia’s rise from the ashes was its emergence as an energy super power. Today Russia is the world’s largest oil producer. Russia is also the world’s largest producer of natural gas and is home to more than a third of global proved reserves of natural gas. The country has become the energy provider for most of Europe and Central Asia. This has provided the Russian Federation with great leverage while dealing with countries in the region. This also meant that the Russian economy by this period was a totally commodity dependent economy. The consequences of this was best understood during the Global recession in 2008 when Russian GDP fell by 7% due to fall in crude prices. However the economy regained growth immediately thereafter.

11.       Today, Russia is growing into a diversified economy. The agriculture has grown immensely and the services and industries sector has shown tremendous potential. Accession to world Trade Organisation in Dec 12, after 15years of negotiation, has provided Russian Manufacturers with newer opportunities.  It must also be said that there was large scale interaction and mutual agreements with the West and US, which contributed to a great extent to the resurgence of Russia.

12.       IT sector has been the fastest growing industry in Russia with an average rate of 10-15% over the last decade. The foundation for Russia’s success in the field has largely been due to its world class science programs in its higher education system, with half of Russia’s higher education students studying science. According to some study, Russia has the third highest per capita concentration of scientists and engineers in the world. Today, Russia is behind only India and China in IT outsourcing and software production.  Space programme is another area which has received big boost in recent times. The Space programme was introduced as one of the key result areas of the then Russian president Medvedev in 2008 and huge sums of money allocated for the purpose. It is important to note that a quarter of the total amount was meant for military space programme.

13.       Defence industry in Russia has been rejuvenated and renergised. Russian defence exports in 2012 alone were worth 15 billion dollars which account for 26% of global sales. Only US, with 30% of global share, is ahead of Russia. Libya was a major Su-35 aircraft purchaser prior to Gadhafi’s death. New discussions between the new Libyan authorities and Russia are expected to resume military cooperation between the two nations. Libya signed a contract for 200 T-72 battle tank modernization, offering Russia another promising buyer as it seeks to build business in the market of restoring, upgrading, and repairing military weapon systems. Russia presently exports military hardware to more than 56 countries. Russian aircraft, radar systems, Air defence systems and ships, which cost only a fraction of the cost of western equipment have been in great demand from many nations. The Russian defence industry is expected to continue its growth rate and increase its share of contribution towards the Russian GDP.


Military Power

14.       Military aspects form an area where Russia has largely lagged behind during her economic resurgence. Most of the equipment are of the soviet vintage and the Military itself needs widespread reforms. Steps to boost morale of personnel, increase efficiency of forces and modernization programme has already been initiated by the authorities. The wages of military personnel and military pensions have been raised two- to three-fold since January  2012, compared to 2007 figures. The Russian Army has, salary-wise, become one of the best employers in the country. Similarly, on the housing front, over 250 billion roubles have been allocated for building housing for retirees. In December 2012, 15,000 servicemen were in waiting for housing, a considerable progress, compared with 160,000 plus servicemen in waiting four years earlier

15.       As per global records of 2012, US tops military spending with 682 billion dollars, accounting for 4.4 percent of GDP. The second place is taken by China with $166 billion (2 percent of GDP), and the third place - by the Russian Federation with $90.7 billion (4.4 per cent).  Russian President in his defender of fatherland day speech in 2013, outlined his priorities to make Russia a military super power, to place where Russia was before. Plans for 770 million dollars additional spending till 2020 aiming to complete 70% modernization of Russian Armed Forces have been finalized. 24% of this amount has been catered for the Navy with 120 billion dollars kept aside for ship building alone.

16.       New Inductions.     During this period, the Russian Forces plan to induct SU-35 and Mig 35 fighter aircraft, T-50 fifth generation stealth fighter, Mi 28 attack helicopter and AN 70 transport aircraft in addition to new generation battle tanks and MSTA-S 152 mm self-propelled howitzer guns. The Yasen-class submarine which will be inducted from 2015 onwards, has been called the quietest sub in the ocean by the Office of Naval Intelligence. It carries up to 32 cruise missiles and is scheduled for ocean deployment by 2015 at a cost of 1.2 billion dollars each. Development of the Bulava, Sineva, and Layner ballistic missiles best describe why Russia is obsessed with submarines. These three submarine-launched ballistic-missiles (SLBM's) are the forefront of Russia's naval missile defense. Additionally, Russia is expanding its littoral water fleet navy with the Steregushchy-class corvette ships. New Destroyers and four new aircraft carriers are in the pipeline with induction likely to begin from 2020 onwards.

Foreign Policy

17.       Russia has been growing more and more assertive over the years. The growing assertiveness is best reflected in the Russian efforts to protect her interest and her citizens across the globe. Russian military intervention in Georgia in 2008, coercion of Baltic republics to accept Russian terms and the more recent adoption of anti-adoption legislation aimed against US are also indicative of Russia’s growing power. Russia has made it publicly known about its desire to influence the world order against the hegemony of US. In keeping with this, Russia has been strongly voicing her opinion in the International Community on issues ranging from Afghanistan, Libya, Iran and Syria. Abandonment of the Strategic Missile Shield System for Europe by none other than the US is the best example of the world accepting the Russian reemergence.

18.       Russia has also launched diplomatic initiatives to strengthen her relations with the former soviet republics and East European nations. Formation of a Eurasian Economic Community is widely seen an effort by the Russian administration to form an alliance to compete with the European Union. It is expected that the Eurasian Union will have the Caucasian and Central Asian Republics as its members by 2015 and more countries of Eastern Europe in the coming years. Russia also has growing relationship with China and a historical relationship with India, both emerging powers. Further, Russia is in the process of carving out its own space in the African region by providing them military assistance.

Future Prospects

19.       At 17,075,400 square kilometres, Russia is the largest country in the world, covering more than one-eighth of the Earth's inhabited land area. Russia is also the world's ninth most populous nation with 143 million people as of 2012. Extending across the whole of northern Asia, Russia spans nine time zones and incorporates a wide range of environments and landforms. Presently, the Russian economy is the  eighth largest by nominal GDP and sixth largest by purchasing power parity. Russia's extensive mineral and energy reserves are considered to be the largest in the world.  The country is one of the five recognized nuclear weapons states. In addition to being a permanent member of the United Nations Security Council, Russia is a member of the G8, G20, the Council of Europe, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation, the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, the Eurasian Economic Community, the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and most recently the World Trade Organisation(WTO).

20.       Current Russian President Vladimir Putin has made no secret of his ambitions to regain the country’s lost glory. Today, Russia is already wielding its influence in many spheres and regions around the world.  Establishment of a Eurasian Union and plans to expand it by 2015 to cover all nations of Central Asia and likeminded nations of Caucasus and East Europe is further indication of the rise of Russian influence. It can be rightly said that Russia has already emerged from shadows and is keenly promoting own ideologies. Considering the global status and influence of Russia, it can be said in no uncertain terms that Russia is fast emerging in to a world power. As on today, Russia is at best an influential nation and cannot be considered as a super power at par with USA.  However, Russia is on the rise and if the rise continues at the current rate, it will not be long before Russia is considered a super power again. The country certainly has the military might, natural resources, a large population and the national will to succeed. Where it lacks though, is on the economy front which with the ongoing efforts are expected to strengthen further in the coming years.